Best Vacation Rental Property Management Companies Compared (2026 Review)
Compare the top vacation rental property management companies with insights on services, fees, and performance to help you choose the right partner.
Short-term rentals keep expanding, but supply is growing even faster. In its October 2025 U.S. outlook, AirDNA projects demand will inch up only 10 percent by 2026 while average occupancy stays near 55 percent—so more homes will fight for the same guests. In a crowded market, the right vacation-rental property manager can turn your empty weekends into fully booked stays.
We dug into 2025 performance data, merger filings, and owner reviews to rank seven standout managers—from local-franchise SkyRun and nationwide giant Vacasa to budget-friendly Evolve. Use this guide to pick the partner that raises revenue and lowers stress in 2026.
How We Picked and Scored the Final Seven
We started with more than 30 national and multi-market managers, then cut any firm that 1) hides its fees or 2) operates in fewer than ten vacation markets.
To keep the process familiar, we borrowed Realty Times’ six-pillar rubric: fees, revenue impact, guest satisfaction, technology, local reach, and unique perks. We then re-weighted each pillar to match what owners say matters most:
Owner ROI: 30 percent
Transparent fees: 20 percent
Tech + marketing reach: 15 percent
Guest/owner satisfaction: 15 percent
Operational depth: 10 percent
Value-adds (guarantees, design): 10 percent
Our data set blended company disclosures, 2025 Trustpilot scores, and the November 2025 SimpleShowing fee study. That research confirmed today’s price bands: roughly 25 to 30 percent for full-service plans, about 20 percent for hybrid models, and close to 10 percent for marketing-only options.
We verified every performance claim against owner reviews or third-party coverage. If we couldn’t confirm it, we cut it. The result is a ranking built on evidence, not buzz.
The Fast-Track Cheat Sheet
Want the big picture before the deep dive? The table below compares fees, service style, contract terms, and recent Trustpilot scores for all seven finalists.
Source: Trustpilot ratings captured October 2025; fee ranges from the SimpleShowing fee study, November 2025.
Two-minute takeaway: SkyRun wins on local accountability, Vacasa on pure reach, and Evolve on cost. AvantStay is the design-focused luxury choice, while iTrip, Grand Welcome, and VTrips balance price with a personal touch.
1. SkyRun Vacation Rentals: Local Heart, Big-brand Backbone
SkyRun property management pairs you with a franchise owner who lives where your guests vacation, not a distant call center. That local stake often means quicker fixes, cleaner homes, and a manager who sweats every five-star review.
The footprint is larger than many owners expect: more than 1,300 homes across 40 markets as of June 2025. Realty Times reports that owners who switch to SkyRun enjoy about 30 percent more booked nights in the first year, thanks to daily dynamic pricing and hands-on service.
SkyRun’s fees flex with your workload:
Full service: roughly 20–25 percent of gross rent
Co-host tier: around 15 percent if you handle cleaning or light maintenance
Guaranteed income: available in select markets for predictable cash flow
Behind the scenes, SkyRun adopted PriceLabs’ AI-powered revenue platform in 2024. Rates update daily across Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com. Owners track it all in a real-time dashboard while the local franchisee vets cleaners, meets inspectors, and handles middle-of-the-night lock-code calls.
Quality depends on the individual franchise. A seasoned mountain office often delivers concierge-level care, while a new beach location could still be hiring cleaners. Interview your specific operator, request references, and scan local reviews—not just the national average.
Best for owners who want a partner, not just a platform. If you need someone a text away and backed by solid technology, SkyRun earns its top spot.
2. Vacasa (part of Casago): Big Tech, Bigger Footprint
After merging with Casago in May 2025, Vacasa now manages about 40,000 vacation homes across North America, Belize, Costa Rica, and the Caribbean. That reach brings advantages few independents can match. A proprietary pricing engine adjusts rates hundreds of times per day, listings appear on more than 40 booking channels, and a 24/7 guest-support center handles everything from lockouts to leaking faucets.
You will pay for that scale. The November 2025 SimpleShowing study pegs Vacasa’s full-service commission at 25–30 percent of gross rent. Its lighter GuestWorks plan sits near 10 percent for owners who handle cleaning and maintenance. In either tier, Vacasa stages photos, writes listings, secures permits, schedules professional cleans, and includes basic damage protection. Owners simply open the app and watch bookings land.
Guest feedback supports the promise. More than 16,000 Trustpilot posts average 4.4 stars as of October 2025, an impressive score for a company this size.
The trade-off is personal touch. Some owners note rotating contacts or slower replies in peak season, and the standard contract lasts twelve months, so an early exit requires notice and a calendar hand-off.
Best fit: out-of-town investors who want total convenience and are willing to pay a premium to avoid day-to-day chores. If you judge success by net dollars without opening Airbnb once, Vacasa still delivers.
3. Evolve: Marketing Muscle at a Bargain Price
Evolve runs lean. For a flat 10 percent booking fee, it handles the front-end work: professional photos, listing copy, multi-channel ads, dynamic pricing, and round-the-clock guest messaging. You (or your caretaker) take care of cleaning, restocking, and any late-night repairs.
Why owners pick this model: a cabin that grosses $80,000 pays Evolve $8,000 in commission, compared with more than $20,000 at a 25 percent full-service firm. The terms help, too. There is no long-term contract, and a six-month fee-back guarantee protects you if results disappoint. That risk-free stance supports a 4.1-star average across more than 5,000 Trustpilot reviews as of October 2025.
The trade-off is on-site help. Evolve will alert guests when the water heater fails, but arranging the plumber is still on you. In 2025 the company added a 15 percent “Platinum” tier with preferred vendors and extra insurance, yet it still stops short of full service.
Best for owners who live nearby—or have a dependable local crew—and want maximum net profit without a long commitment. If you are organized and prefer to keep control of on-the-ground tasks, Evolve is hard to beat.
4. AvantStay: Turning Homes into Boutique Hotels
AvantStay focuses on large, photogenic properties and transforms each house into a mini hotel. Its in-house design team reimagines every room (picture fire-pit lounges and neon game rooms) so listings pop on social feeds and earn four-figure nightly rates.
That design expertise explains the 20–25 percent commission and multi-year contract. AvantStay fronts the décor budget and needs time to recoup the spend. The Los Angeles-based brand now manages more than 600 luxury homes in 30 markets across the United States and Mexico.
Guests respond well to the upgrade. AvantStay holds a 4.6-star average from roughly 1,900 Trustpilot reviews captured in October 2025, and many guests describe the homes as “private hotels.” Perks support the premium feel: a guest concierge app for grocery delivery and chef referrals, a one-million-dollar liability policy, automated permit filing, and wide distribution on Airbnb, Vrbo, Marriott Homes & Villas, and AvantStay’s own site.
Trade-off: control. AvantStay limits owner stays during peak weeks and gives its design team final say on décor. If you want full creative control—or need the beach house every July Fourth—consider another manager.
Ideal fit: owners who treat the property as an investment first. Let AvantStay stage the home, then watch nightly rates and long-term asset value rise.
5. iTrip Vacations: Franchise Pioneer with Mixed Reviews
iTrip began franchising local managers in 2008, long before “Airbnb management” became a buzzword. Today more than 100 franchisees oversee roughly 3,200 properties in over 120 U.S. markets. Each location taps iTrip’s marketing platform, pricing tools, and orange-and-blue brand, yet day-to-day service depends on the local owner.
That structure cuts both ways. A seasoned husband-and-wife team in Gulf Shores may deliver spotless turnovers, while a new office two states away could still be finding its footing. The national Trustpilot average is 1.4 stars from about 140 reviews (captured October 2025), so vet the specific office that will manage your home.
Fees: 18 to 25 percent commission, often a bit lower than Vacasa or SkyRun full service
Contract: one-year term with reasonable exit clauses
Operations: cleaning and maintenance included, but details vary; some provide linens, others bill at cost
Tech: centralized dynamic pricing, multi-channel distribution, and an owner portal similar to larger brands
Ideal fit: owners who value a personal relationship but still want national-level marketing. Interview the franchisee, ask for references, and even stay a night in one of their listings before you sign.
Design Matters: Will Your Manager Upgrade the Look?
Eye-catching interiors do more than earn compliments; they lift revenue. An October 2025 AirDNA brief found that listings with fresh décor command 10 to 20 percent higher average daily rates than similar homes in the same zip code. Yet most management contracts stay silent on style. Here is what you can expect:
Full-service corporates (Vacasa, VTrips)
Operations come first. They will photograph and market the home as-is. If the couch is from 2008, guests will see it.
Franchise operators (SkyRun, iTrip, Grand Welcome)
Guidance, not makeovers. A proactive franchisee may suggest bunk beds or a fire pit and connect you to local stagers, but the spend and decisions stay with you.
Evolve (marketing only)
Even lighter touch. You handle on-site work, so décor upgrades are your call. Evolve’s role is to showcase the new photos once the paint dries.
AvantStay (the outlier)
An in-house design team overhauls the property during onboarding, often fronting furniture at trade cost. Expect coordinated palettes, neon game-room signs, and hotel-style amenities that boost nightly rates into four figures. In return, you sign a multi-year contract and give up aesthetic veto power.
Bottom line: if a refresh sits on your 2026 to-do list, budget for it unless you hire a design-centric specialist like AvantStay. A five-figure remodel can feel steep, yet in crowded markets distinctive interiors remain one of the quickest ways to stand out and raise both nightly rate and review scores.
Buyer’s Guide: Match the Manager to Your Goals
Use this five-point checklist to narrow options beyond the headline rankings.
Bandwidth Live across the country or want hands-off income? Choose full-service operators like Vacasa, SkyRun’s top tier, or VTrips. You will pay about twenty-five to thirty percent of gross rent, but you will never field midnight plumbing calls.
Local and handy? A lean model may net more. Evolve charges ten percent, while vacation-rental property-management franchise SkyRun’s co-host tier lands near fifteen percent—yet owners report earning up to 30 percent more revenue after switching, thanks to its AI-driven dynamic pricing.
Personal use Need the beach house every July Fourth? Evolve and most franchises let you block any dates. AvantStay locks peak weeks to protect revenue, so read that clause twice.
Math, not marketing Ask each company for a pro-forma that shows projected nights, average daily rate, cleaning costs, and net owner payout. Compare it with last year’s actuals or a conservative market comp; a twenty-five percent manager can still beat a fifteen percent option if they fill shoulder seasons. For an easy way to line those proposals up side by side, you can plug the numbers into a simple vacation-rental manager scorecard that weights fees, service quality, and performance, like this vacation-rental manager scorecard guide.
Local team quality Interview the people who will touch your home. How many properties do they juggle? Do they inspect every turnover? A sharp local crew inside a smaller brand often outperforms a famous logo managed from afar.
Regulation help Cities such as New York and Dallas now impose steep fines for permit missteps. Vacasa and VTrips file paperwork in-house; Evolve sends reminders but leaves filing to you. In rule-heavy markets, pick a partner that stands in the compliance gap.
What’s Next: Five Trends Shaping Vacation-Rental Management in 2026
AI-powered pricing goes mainstream Professional managers now blend flight searches, local ticket sales, and even real-time weather into algorithms that can adjust rates fifty to one hundred times per day, according to AirDNA client benchmarks published in October 2025. Ask each company how often—and how transparently—they update prices.
Consolidation accelerates Casago’s 2025 purchase of Vacasa showed that scale alone is not enough without local accountability. Expect more “tech plus local” mergers. Contracts may change hands mid-term, so build assignment or termination clauses into any agreement.
Regulation gets tougher Cities from New York to Dallas have moved from simple registrations to caps and steep fines. Dallas now requires a one-hour local contact and can suspend a whole portfolio after two violations. Choose a manager that files permits, pays taxes, and installs noise sensors.
Guest expectations keep rising What was once a premium—mid-stay cleans, grocery delivery, round-the-clock chat—is edging toward baseline. Managers that upsell extras such as private chefs or lift tickets report higher average order values and stronger five-star reviews, per 2025 Hostfully data.
Design becomes a revenue lever With United States supply up fourteen percent since 2022, and search algorithms rewarding photo quality, listings that look magazine-ready capture more clicks and command up to twenty percent higher average daily rate. If your manager will not handle décor, budget for a refresh yourself or hire a design-focused firm like AvantStay.
Conclusion
Bottom line: technology, regulation, service depth, and aesthetics will separate winners from laggards over the next eighteen months. The right partner is not just the one with the lowest fee, but the one that can consistently fill your calendar, protect your permits, and keep both guests and cleaners happy. Whether that looks like Vacasa’s end-to-end operations, SkyRun’s franchise model, Evolve’s lean marketing-only approach, or AvantStay’s design-first strategy depends on how close you live to the property, how often you plan to use it, and how comfortable you are handing over control.
Your next move is to treat this search like hiring for a six-figure job. Shortlist two or three managers that match your bandwidth and budget, ask each for a detailed pro-forma, and pressure-test their assumptions against your past numbers or conservative comps. Then dig into the local team: read recent reviews in your specific market, ask how many homes they oversee, and clarify who handles permits, inspections, and damage claims. In a 55-percent-occupancy world, owners who take the time to vet the right manager now will be the ones looking at stronger cash flow—and better-protected assets—by the end of 2026.
Stay up to date with our latest ideas!
